Was looking forward to trying this restaurant. I was very disappointed in the Pizza. It wasn't cooked whatsoever, the onions were hard and there was absolutely no tomato sauce. It just wasn't blended like a pizza should be (not put together...hard). If I had opened the box, before I left the restaurant, I would have seen no sauce and said something. The cost of the pizza was around $16.75 and I feel I was robbed. ....I hardly ever give bad reviews and am hoping this helps the restaurant in the future. Maybe there pizzas will be better, but I will never know. To serve this, I would be ashamed. I can only maybe think that someone made a mistake somewhere, and just heated up a pizza from the freezer, and never cooked it or made sauce for it. Something is definitely not right there, and to think that they can get away with serving pizza like that for $16.00. It wasn't even worth $5.
I'm not the only one who had this pizza, they agree with me totally. Too bad.

These guys are great! The best focchia and a good sauce! Funky home style place.We love the food.They used to be in Yonkers and when we moved here we missed them and were very happy when they moved to poughkeepsie.A really nice neighborhood place!

I live at Hopewell Jct about five miles away from GOOD FELLAS PIZZA.
First i would like to compliment the guys for their service they do,also for the food they make it tastes DELICIOUS.
I love going for lunch and dinners at their pizza shop.
Also i would recommend going there for lunch and/or dinner.
Everyone that i know who goes there always compliments them on how great they make their food,pizzas,and the high class servings.